Biology Atlas

Map / Open register

question · intermediate · partly written

How many genes in the simplest cell do we still not understand, and what does that mean?

How many genes in the simplest cell do we still not understand, and does that signal a missing principle or an annotation backlog?

His claim

He said: "there are actually still around 70 to 90 genes that we still don't fully understand, right? That, to me, is a sign that there's some deep biological issue that we can't fully explain." 1

Amit's hypothesis

What the sources say about his number

70 to 90 matches one count of one cell: the syn3A 'unclear function' genes, 91 in 2019 and 87 in 2022. No source defines a set of 70 to 90. Other schemes give other counts, so a count is a statement about a labelling rule as much as about biology. 23

Reported, not yet replicated

The counts side by side more

syn3.0, 2016: 149 of 473 genes (generic 84 plus unknown 65), a different class scheme. syn3A, 2019: 91 of 452 'unclear function'. syn3A, 2022: 87 of 452, set by the authors against E. coli 1,780 of 4,637 and M. pneumoniae 311 of 688 under their own scheme. syn3.0, 2026 recount: about 50 to 60 proteins without function, 12 given computational guesses. E. coli K-12, 2019: 1,600 of 4,623 (34.6%). E. coli, 2024: 738 of 4,747 (15.5%) after adding a middle 'Partial' tier of 1,247. Do not read 149 against 91 as progress: they are different classes. The 87 and the E. coli 1,780 are from the 2022 paper's text as read once; a later check could not re-open that PDF. 423567

Reported, not yet replicated

What 'we do not understand this gene' means in each case more

Three levels appear. No activity at all is known. A recognisable type without substrate (a 'generic' class, such as a transporter of unknown substrate). Essential but unexplained: the 30 syn3A genes that stop growth when disrupted and have no known function. In E. coli the 2019 rule means no experimental evidence of a mechanism; the 2024 rule separates Uncharacterized from Partial, and a 'putative' in the product name can place a gene in Partial whatever evidence stands behind it. 2467

Reported, not yet replicated

Where the list lives more

The 30 essential unexplained syn3A genes are in Supplementary file 3 of the 2019 paper (filter: class Unclear, essentiality Essential), a public spreadsheet opened in this run. They are not mostly transporters by the source's own classes: transporters form a separate class there. The E. coli 2019 list is in that paper's supplement; the 2024 gene lists are in a figshare supplement that was not opened. 267

Reported, not yet replicated

What the evidence says about 'a deep biological issue' more

The evidence read does not show that unknown genes in the simplest cell mean a missing principle, and no source read claims it. The authors of the syn3A essentiality study wrote that the essential unclear genes could represent new biological mechanisms, which is a possibility, not a finding. Against it, computational methods have proposed functions for a growing share, the class leans toward membrane proteins that are hard to assay, and the E. coli count fell by more than half through relabelling rather than discovery. No bench resolution of any of the roughly 90 syn3A genes was found in an abstract-level search of the literature since 2019, so the evidence neither confirms nor refutes his reading. 285967

Our inference

Observation

In the minimal synthetic cell JCVI-syn3A, 91 of 452 protein genes were of unclear function in 2019 (30 essential, 32 quasi-essential, 29 non-essential) and 87 in the 2022 model paper's count; in E. coli K-12, 1,600 of 4,623 genes lacked experimental evidence of function in 2019 and 738 of 4,747 were Uncharacterized in 2024. 2367

Reported, not yet replicated

Hypotheses

A missing mechanism

Some of the essential unexplained genes carry biochemistry that is new, so the gap is in biology, not in the annotation pipeline. The 2019 authors state that these genes could represent new biological mechanisms. 2

Predicts. When tested at the bench, some essential unclear genes show activities that match no known family, and they resist structure- and sequence-based transfer even when the assay is guided by predictions.

Would falsify. Most of the 27 genes without accepted function resolving into known families or known reaction types once assayed.

Our inference

An annotation and measurement backlog

The unknown genes are hard to assay (many are membrane proteins) and have simply not been tested, so most will resolve into known biochemistry. Computation already assigned functions to some. 985

Predicts. Counts fall as methods and assays improve; the unknowns are enriched in membrane proteins; function transfer succeeds for a rising share.

Would falsify. A systematic experimental effort on the essential unclear genes finding that a large share have no known-family function, or computational calls failing at the bench for most of them.

Our inference

The headline count is mostly a labelling rule

A count of unknown genes depends on the evidence threshold and denominator, so a single figure for 'how many we do not understand' is not well defined. 67

Predicts. The same genome gives different unknown counts under different published rules.

Would falsify. Two independent rules applied to one genome giving the same count with the same genes.

Reported, not yet replicated

What is missing

A bench tally for the essential unclear genes

No experimentally resolved function for a specific unknown gene, and no running tally, was found in an abstract-level search of 2019 to 2026 syn3A literature; full texts were not opened, so a result inside one cannot be excluded. 2

Reported, not yet replicated

A measured accuracy for function calls on these genes

Structure-based methods are benchmarked against existing labels; no wet-lab test of a structure-derived syn3A call was found. 910

Reported, not yet replicated

A gene-by-gene move table for E. coli

The paper does not report which genes moved between the 2019 and 2024 schemes. 7

Reported, not yet replicated

What is known

A count of syn3A protein genes of unclear function exists (91 in 2019, 87 in the 2022 model paper) with the 30 essential ones listed in a public supplement; E. coli's unknown share depends on the rule (34.6% in 2019, 15.5% in 2024); computational methods have proposed functions for many. 2367

Reported, not yet replicated

What is not

Which of the essential unclear genes would turn out to be new biochemistry; whether any structure-derived function is right at the bench; how much of E. coli's fall in unknowns is new experiments. 27

Reported, not yet replicated

What would settle it

A characterised essential gene whose activity is chemically new would support a missing mechanism; most of the 27 resolving into known families under experiment would support a backlog. Nobody has run either tally. A rule-stable gene-by-gene diff of the E. coli lists would separate relabelling from discovery there. 27

Our inference

Still open here

Not yet written: Who works on it.

Linked from

Sources

  1. Amit's words about the atlas, kept verbatim in this repository. Kept in the atlas repository; not published.
  2. Breuer M, Earnest TM, Merryman C, et al.. Essential metabolism for a minimal cell. eLife (2019). paper; opened 2026-11-17 all records citing this
  3. Thornburg ZR, Bianchi DM, Brier TA, et al.. Fundamental behaviors emerge from simulations of a living minimal cell. Cell (2022). paper; opened 2026-11-17 all records citing this
  4. Hutchison CA, Chuang RY, Noskov VN, et al.. Design and synthesis of a minimal bacterial genome. Science 351:aad6253 (2016). paper; opened 2026-11-17 all records citing this
  5. Mushegian AR, Yamamoto PK, Torikai N, Arakawa K. Minimal organism JCVI-syn3.0, an engineered derivative of Mycoplasma mycoides, encodes an assortment of unrecognized membrane transporters and immunity factors. mSphere (2026). paper; opened 2026-11-17 all records citing this
  6. Ghatak S, King ZA, Sastry A, Palsson BO. The y-ome defines the 35% of Escherichia coli genes that lack experimental evidence of function. Nucleic Acids Research 47(5) (2019). paper; opened 2026-11-17 all records citing this
  7. Moore LR, Caspi R, Boyd D, et al., Karp PD. Revisiting the y-ome of Escherichia coli. Nucleic Acids Research (2024). paper; opened 2026-11-17 all records citing this
  8. Zhang C, Zheng W, Cheng M, Omenn GS, Freddolino PL, Zhang Y. Functions of Essential Genes and a Scale-Free Protein Interaction Network Revealed by Structure-Based Function and Interaction Prediction for a Minimal Genome. Journal of Proteome Research (2021). paper; opened 2026-11-17 all records citing this
  9. Antczak M, Michaelis M, Wass MN. Environmental conditions shape the nature of a minimal bacterial genome. Nature Communications (2019). paper; opened 2026-11-17 all records citing this
  10. Bianchi DM, Pelletier JF, Hutchison CA, Glass JI, Luthey-Schulten Z. Toward the Complete Functional Characterization of a Minimal Bacterial Proteome. Journal of Physical Chemistry B (2022). paper; opened 2026-11-17 all records citing this
History of this record (2)

This record has been changed 2 times, on the dates below. The note kept against each change is written for the people who maintain the atlas, in their own shorthand, so it is not shown here; it is in the record itself.

Kind
amit
Register
open-question
Status
partly written
Last updated
2026-11-17
Record
content/questions/unknown-genes-in-a-minimal-cell.json