question · intermediate · partly written
What drives offset pi stacking: quadrupole electrostatics or dispersion against repulsion?
The textbook Hunter-Sanders explanation is disputed; a 2020 critique and a 2025 defence use the same kinds of calculation on isolated dimers.
Observation
A 2020 critique argued offset geometry comes from steric repulsion of pi-electron clouds, not Coulomb repulsion; Wheeler's 2025 paper says the critique's test data were flawed and that the correctly implemented model is qualitatively right for many dimers but has genuine failures (the sandwich geometry is -0.2 against -1.8 kcal/mol by SAPT). 12
Contested
Hypotheses
Hunter-Sanders (quadrupole electrostatics)
Offset geometry arises from electrostatic repulsion between pi clouds with a sigma-framework attraction. 12
Predicts. Substituent effects follow polarisation in the way the potential gives (r2 0.91, RMSE 0.2 kcal/mol over 17 dimers).
Would falsify. Offset stacking persisting for systems with no electrostatic attraction, or the potential failing over a broad independent set.
Contested
Dispersion against Pauli repulsion
Offset geometry arises from exchange repulsion between pi clouds balanced by dispersion; electrostatics play a smaller role. 12
Predicts. Offset stacking persists even where quadrupole electrostatics are switched off or reversed.
Would falsify. The model's data on test dimers shown to be flawed (the defence claims this).
Contested
What is missing
What is known
What is not
What would settle it
Still open here
- What drives offset stacking in water inside a protein; the primary 2020 and 1990 papers were not read.
Not yet written: Who works on it.
Linked from
Sources
- Wheeler, S. E.. Revisiting the Hunter-Sanders model for pi-pi interactions. Journal of the American Chemical Society (2025). paper; opened 2026-11-17 all records citing this
- Vernon, R. M., Chong, P. A., Tsang, B., et al.. Pi-pi contacts are an overlooked protein feature relevant to phase separation. eLife (2018). paper; opened 2026-11-17 all records citing this
History of this record (1)
This record has been changed 1 time, on the dates below. The note kept against each change is written for the people who maintain the atlas, in their own shorthand, so it is not shown here; it is in the record itself.
- Kind
- big-open
- Register
- open-question
- Triage
- needs-research
- Status
- partly written
- Last updated
- 2026-11-17
- Record
- content/questions/pi-stacking-electrostatics-or-dispersion.json