question · deep · partly written
How faithfully is DNA methylation copied at each division, and does it depend on the CpG context?
How faithfully a CpG site keeps its methylation through one cell division, and whether isolated sites, clustered sites, islands and non-islands differ, has no published per-site, per-division number.
The short version
One locus gives about 0.96 per site per division, refit to a failure of 0.024 once conversion error is modelled. No source splits the rate by CpG context. Two methods point the same way: isolated CpGs are copied worst. 1234
Reported, not yet replicated
The locus figure and its refit more
Hairpin-bisulfite reads the methylation of both strands of a single DNA molecule, so a half-methylated dyad shows a copying failure. At the hypermethylated FMR1 island the maintenance efficiency was estimated at about 0.96 per site per cell division and de novo methylation at 0.17 on the same island and below 0.01 on the hypomethylated island of the active X. A Bayesian refit of a hairpin data set at the same locus estimated an inappropriate-conversion error of 1.6% (80% CI 0.9 to 2.3%) and a lower maintenance failure (0.04 to 0.024). The two values are the same measurement, not independent ones, and neither is a genome-wide rate. 12
Reported, not yet replicated
Genome-scale snapshots and kinetics more
In mouse embryonic stem cells a genome-scale hairpin-bisulfite approach found average dyad fidelity of 88.5% before and 91.9% after six days of differentiation, with fidelity high at promoters of expressed genes. That is a state at one time, not a division-by-division rate. Hammer-seq measured maintenance kinetics after the replication fork: replication-coupled and slower replication-uncoupled phases, with solo-WCGW sites and sites that lose methylation in ageing and cancer showing low maintenance efficiency. Dyad-seq reports fidelity directly related to local methylation density. 534
Reported, not yet replicated
Why the numbers cannot be merged deep
The sources differ in locus versus genome, cell identity, assay and what is measured (a dyad state, a lag, a failure per division). A reader should not convert one into another. Dyad-seq is a preprint here, and its journal version, if any, was not opened. 12534
Reported, not yet replicated
Observation
The best-measured per-division figure comes from one locus: about 0.96 per site per division at the hypermethylated CpG island of the human FMR1 gene by hairpin-bisulfite sequencing. A refit of the same data that models bisulfite conversion error (1.6%) lowers the estimated maintenance failure from 0.04 to 0.024. Genome-scale hairpin data in mouse stem cells give a snapshot of dyad fidelity (average 88.5% in undifferentiated cells), not a rate. Hammer-seq and Dyad-seq indicate the direction of a context effect without giving the split as numbers. 12534
“the average methylation fidelity is as high as 88.5% and 91.9% for E14-d0 and E14-d6, respectively” The dynamics of DNA methylation fidelity during mouse embryonic stem cell self-renewal and differentiation, Results, text on average methylation fidelity
Reported, not yet replicated
Hypotheses
Local methylation density sets copying fidelity
Maintenance is more faithful where neighbouring CpGs are methylated, so isolated CpGs lose methylation faster than clustered ones. 43
Predicts. Isolated CpGs (such as solo-WCGW sites) have lower per-division maintenance than CpGs in dense methylated stretches, in the same cells and with the same assay.
Would falsify. A per-CpG, per-division measurement with assay error modelled that shows isolated CpGs copied as faithfully as clustered ones.
Reported, not yet replicated
Chromatin context modulates maintenance
Histone modifications and nucleosome occupancy change how well DNMT1 copies methylation, especially in lowly methylated regions. 43
Predicts. Maintenance efficiency at matched CpG density differs with the histone marks present.
Would falsify. Matched-density CpGs showing no difference in maintenance across chromatin states.
Reported, not yet replicated
Imperfect copying contributes to age-associated hypomethylation
The sites copied least efficiently are those that lose methylation in ageing and cancer. 3
Predicts. Sites with low maintenance efficiency overlap sites with age-associated hypomethylation.
Would falsify. No overlap between the least efficiently maintained sites and the sites that lose methylation with age.
Reported, not yet replicated
What is missing
What is known
What is not
What would settle it
Still open here
- What are the per-CpG, per-division maintenance and de novo rates, split by isolated versus clustered CpG, island versus non-island, in one cell type, with the assay error modelled?
- How much of the lag after the replication fork seen by Hammer-seq becomes a permanent loss at the next division?
Not yet written: Who works on it.
Linked from
Sources
- Laird, C.D., Pleasant, N.D., Clark, A.D., et al.. Hairpin-bisulfite PCR: assessing epigenetic methylation patterns on complementary strands of individual DNA molecules. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A (2004). paper; opened 2026-11-17 all records citing this
- Fu, A.Q., Genereux, D.P., Stoger, R., Laird, C.D., Stephens, M.. Statistical inference of transmission fidelity of DNA methylation patterns over somatic cell divisions in mammals. Annals of Applied Statistics (2010). paper; opened 2026-11-17 all records citing this
- Ming, X., Zhang, Z., Zou, Z., et al.. Kinetics and mechanisms of mitotic inheritance of DNA methylation and their roles in aging-associated methylome deterioration. Cell Research (2020). paper; opened 2026-11-17 all records citing this
- Chialastri, A., Sarkar, S., Schauer, E.E., et al., Dey, S.S.. Combinatorial quantification of 5mC and 5hmC at individual CpG dyads and the transcriptome in single cells reveals modulators of DNA methylation maintenance fidelity. bioRxiv (2023). preprint, not peer reviewed; opened 2026-11-17 all records citing this
- Zhao, L., Sun, M.A., Li, Z., et al.. The dynamics of DNA methylation fidelity during mouse embryonic stem cell self-renewal and differentiation. Genome Research (2014). paper; opened 2026-11-17 all records citing this
Where it sits on the map
History of this record (1)
This record has been changed 1 time, on the dates below. The note kept against each change is written for the people who maintain the atlas, in their own shorthand, so it is not shown here; it is in the record itself.
- Kind
- big-open
- Register
- open-question
- Status
- partly written
- Last updated
- 2026-11-17
- Record
- content/questions/how-faithful-is-methylation-copying-by-cpg-context.json