concept · intermediate · partly written
Logical definitions and reasoners in ontologies
A logical definition states what a term is as a kind of something with a property, so a reasoner can place the term in the hierarchy without anyone typing the link.
Also called: logical definition, genus-differentia, equivalence axiom, OWL reasoner
How it works
A logical definition has the form: X is equivalent to a kind G that has relation R to Y. The Cell Ontology authors give "nucleate erythrocyte", an erythrocyte that has a nucleus. Because "nucleate cell" is defined as a cell that has a nucleus, a reasoner concludes the first is a kind of the second, with no one entering that link. 1
Established
The reasoner ELK more
ELK handles only OWL 2 EL, a restricted fragment whose reasoning time grows polynomially with ontology size. In the authors' 2011 benchmark on a laptop with a one-hour timeout, it classified SNOMED CT (315,489 concepts) in 5.02 s on 4 workers, against 387.1 s for FaCT++ and 509.3 s for Pellet. The Gene Ontology editors report that the full GO reasons in seconds in ELK and in about 10 minutes in HermiT. 23
Reported, not yet replicated
What it did for the Gene Ontology more
The GO editors report that over 32,000 is-a axioms in the then-current release were inferred by reasoning, not entered by hand, and that GO held 27,108 equivalence axioms and 36,125 some-values-from expressions in their table. GO was axiomatised after the fact, and doing so "frequently revealed cryptic inconsistencies". 3
Reported, not yet replicated
Design patterns more
Design patterns (templates for definitions) let editors generate and check many terms consistently; the published method is called Dead Simple OWL Design Patterns. This atlas read only the abstract. 4
Reported, not yet replicated
Measured errors in the logic more
Four experts rated a random sample of 2,836 existential restrictions in OBO Foundry ontologies, and found 23% suspicious (kappa 0.78). The cross products in the Foundry could not be scored reliably (kappa 0.07). This is a measure of the "has relation R to Y" part, not of mappings. 5
Reported, not yet replicated
Where it breaks more
ELK ignores some axioms, such as inverse properties, and the GO developers found certain errors only when they ran HermiT, so a second, fuller reasoner is run periodically. Annotation done outside OWL surfaces domain and range violations only at central submission. 3
Reported, not yet replicated
Not found more
No controlled study of the error rate of logical definitions across the whole of OBO Foundry beyond the one rated sample was found, and no study of how much logical definition improves downstream tasks. 5
Reported, not yet replicated
Plain answer
Why it matters
This is the mechanism that lets an ontology grow past what an editor can check by eye, and the thing a new assay ontology would need to adopt or replace. 3
Our inference
Still open here
- What is the error rate of logical definitions across OBO ontologies today?
- Do logical definitions change any downstream result?
Not yet written: Equation, Real numbers.
Linked from
Sources
- Meehan TF, Masci AM, Abdulla A, Cowell LG, et al.. Logical development of the cell ontology. BMC bioinformatics (2011). paper; opened 2026-11-18 all records citing this
- Kazakov Y, Krötzsch M, Simančík F. Concurrent Classification of $\mathcal{EL}$ Ontologies. Lecture Notes in Computer Science (2011). paper; opened 2026-11-18 all records citing this
- Use of OWL within the Gene Ontology.. paper, not peer reviewed; opened 2026-11-18 all records citing this
- Osumi-Sutherland D, Courtot M, Balhoff JP, Mungall C. Dead simple OWL design patterns. Journal of biomedical semantics (2017). paper; opened 2026-11-18 all records citing this
- Boeker M, Tudose I, Hastings J, Schober D, et al.. Unintended consequences of existential quantifications in biomedical ontologies. BMC bioinformatics (2011). paper; opened 2026-11-18 all records citing this
Where it sits on the map
History of this record (6)
This record has been changed 6 times, on the dates below. The note kept against each change is written for the people who maintain the atlas, in their own shorthand, so it is not shown here; it is in the record itself.
- Status
- partly written
- Last updated
- 2026-11-19
- Record
- content/concepts/logical-definition-and-reasoner.json